In Lauren Campbell's article, The Way
I See it, she argues that the Texas law requiring women to have a sonogram
24 hours prior to having an abortion is reasonable. I personally disagree with
that, and believe that it is not acceptable. Women should not be
manipulated in such a way when faced with an already terribly difficult decision. Lauren argues that the law provides the fetus the right to
be seen for what it really is, a baby, that words like "fetus" serve
to dehumanize it, and that the law is trying to get women to realize what they
are really doing when having an abortion.
First of all, this
is not at all scientifically accurate, as a fetus is not a baby, but an
entirely separate stage in human development, and the term is not intended to
be dehumanizing, but an accurate description. We might as well start calling
each individual sperm or egg a baby now, since it's just as correct. To state
that a mandatory sonogram is necessary for a woman to "realize exactly
what they are doing" is almost insulting to the entire gender. It seems to
imply that women have absolutely no clue how abortions work, like they think
some fairy comes and magically makes them un-pregnant. Of course women are
aware that terminating their pregnancy means that they are killing the unborn
fetus - that's why it's such a difficult decision.
Lauren
goes on to ask, "which do you think would be worse: having a baby as a
teen mom, and either keeping it or giving it up for adoption, OR making a ...
decision to have an abortion and possibly going on to regret it later in life?"
To me, the answer to this question seems entirely obvious - going through 9 months of
pregnancy and the mood swings, depression, weight gain, and all the other
terrible things that accompany it, only to be followed by a painful, not to
mention expensive, childbirth to keep or give the baby for adoption is clearly
much worse of an option. Keeping a child is often an irresponsible idea, as it
is very unlikely that mothers who would be considering abortions are
financially or emotionally capable of adequately taking care of a child. As
this article describes in greater depth, adoption, while it may seem like the
nobler course of action, is also very difficult. It’s costly, and on top of
that quite unsuccessful – thousands of American children are currently being held
under state care without being adopted. It’s not as simple as handing your baby
to a new family once it’s born.
The
choice to have an abortion is an incredibly difficult one, and the new law
requiring sonograms while a woman is most emotionally vulnerable only makes the
decision harder. The law is not intended to simply allow women to "think twice" about their decision, but to forcibly persuade them to change their mind. It is cruel and manipulative, and should be revoked as
soon as possible.
No comments:
Post a Comment